Captaincy Woes

Aussie captains caught in trouble

When Sandpapergate was being dealt with; Tim Paine was appointed the new Test captain when Steve Smith was dropped and banned for a year. His captaincy wasn't as successful as his predecessor but he did a good job.

However, his captaincy, as well as his career, ended with a scandal of his own.

Tim Paine has quit as Test captain less than three weeks before the men's Ashes after the emergence of an investigation four years ago by Cricket Australia for sending explicit messages to a female co-worker.

Paine, who has been facing a race against time to be fit for the first Ashes Test on December 8, was named in a News Corp report as being at the centre of the case.

He faced the media in Hobart to announce he was resigning but will remain available for selection for the Ashes. The messages date back to 2017, shortly before Paine was recalled to the Test team after a seven-year absence and a joint Cricket Australia (CA) and Cricket Tasmania investigation cleared him at the time.

"Today, I'm announcing my decision to stand down as the captain of the Australian men's test team. It's an incredibly difficult decision but the right one for me, my family, and cricket," Paine said as he read out a statement.

"As a background on my decision, nearly four years ago, I was involved in a text exchange with a then-colleague. At the time, the exchange was the subject of a thorough CA Integrity Unit investigation; throughout which I fully participated in and openly participated in."

That investigation and a Cricket Tasmania HR investigation at the same time found that there had been no breach of the Cricket Australia Code of Conduct. "Although exonerated, I deeply regretted this incident at the time and still do today. I spoke to my wife and family at the time and am enormously grateful for their forgiveness and support. We thought this incident was behind us and that I could focus entirely on the team; as I have done for the last three or four years.

"However, I recently became aware that this private text exchange was going to become public. On reflection, my actions in 2017 do not meet the standard of an Australian cricket captain, or the wider community. I'm deeply sorry for the hurt and pain that I have caused to my wife, my family, and to the other party. I'm sorry for any damage that this does to the reputation of our sport."

He added that he felt resignation was his only option and apologised to team-mates and supporters.

"I believe that it is the right decision for me to stand down as captain, effective immediately," he said. "I do not want this to become an unwelcome disruption to the team ahead of what is a huge Ashes series."

"It's been the greatest privilege of my sporting life to lead the Australian men's test team. I'm grateful for the support of my team-mates and proud of what we've been able to achieve together."

"To them, I ask for their understanding and forgiveness. To Australian cricket fans I'm deeply sorry that my past behaviour has impacted our game on the eve of the Ashes. For the disappointment I have caused to fans and the entire cricket community, I apologise."

"I've been blessed with a wonderful, loving and supportive family and it breaks my heart to know how much I've let them down. They have always stood by me, been my most loyal fans, and I'm indebted to them for their support."

"I will remain a committed member of the Australian cricket team and look forward with anticipation to what is a huge Ashes tour."

A subsequent statement by Cricket Tasmania said the allegations had only been brought to their attention when theft charges were laid against the employee in mid-2018 and that no complaint had been made at the time of the messages in November 2017.

"As soon as Cricket Tasmania was made aware, it undertook an investigation that determined the interaction was consensual, private, occurred on the one occasion only, was between mature adults and was not repeated," Cricket Tasmania chairman Andrew Gaggin said.

"Cricket Tasmania clearly does not condone this type of behaviour and addressed the matter directly with Tim Paine. However, because of the consensual nature of the actions it was determined that no further action was required or appropriate."

Paine was elevated to the captaincy in March 2018 following the explosive fallout from the ball-tampering scandal in South Africa. Fast bowler Pat Cummins is Australia's current vice-captain and had been tipped to assume the role once Paine retired.

The board accepted Paine's resignation and has said that process of identifying and appointing a new Test captain will be accelerated. "Tim felt it was in the best interests of his family and Australian cricket to take this decision to step down as captain," CA chair Richard Freudenstein said. "The Board has accepted Tim's resignation and will now work through a process with the National Selection Panel of identifying and appointing a new captain."

"While the Board acknowledges an investigation cleared Tim of any breach of the code of conduct regarding this matter some years ago; we respect his decision. CA does not condone this type of language or behaviour. Despite the mistake he made, Tim has been an exceptional leader since his appointment and the Board thanks him for his distinguished service."

"Tim will continue to be available for selection in the Test team through the Ashes summer."

Tim Paine took the Australian Test captaincy with the men's team in the midst of a crisis and he leaves with them plunged back into another one.

Very rarely do captaincy tenures end in a good way - it's not the nature of the job - but to lose consecutive Test leaders the way they have doesn't paint CA in a good light.

The board and the executive, albeit one with very few survivors from 2018 when CA was shredded by the fallout of the Newlands scandal, have some important questions that need answering. The timeline revealed on Friday said that the complaint was made about Paine's messages in June 2018.

In a previous era, the Australian Cricket Board, as it was then, was found out for having tried to keep a controversy under wraps with Mark Waugh and Shane Warne's links to a bookmaker in the mid-1990s. The story eventually emerged midway through the 1998 Ashes series. As, so often, these things emerge.

By June 2018, Paine was already installed as the Test captain and at that moment was leading the side on a limited-overs tour of England. A few months later, following the publication of the culture review into Australian cricket; Paine was front and centre in acclaiming a "player pact" to usher in a new era for the team as they looked to rebuild their image.

However, lurking in the files at Jolimont were the complaints and investigations into Paine's messages. The outcome that Paine was found not to have breached the code of conduct and that the messages were between consenting adults was enough for the case to be put away and kept in-house. When they have been hidden away for so long, the fallout is even greater.

We don't know the full extent of conversations that were had regarding Paine's captaincy credentials at the time but clearly the outcome was that he was deemed suitable to continue.

The fact he was cleared of any offence by the investigation does not necessarily equate to him still being a fitting captain. That this came at a time when CA was pushing a new image for the men's team so strongly makes it appear even more mismanaged. There will be a few who won't be slow to jump on some of Paine's utterances over the last few years in the wake of his departure.

Amid his tearful resignation, Paine said he was determined to remain a player for the Ashes series. It was a notion supported by the board. The Australia Cricketers' Association, the players' union, went a step further in a statement by saying they were "saddened that he felt the need to resign."

Some of the commentary around his batting returns have been over-egged - his average of 32.63 is comparable to that of Englishmen, Jos Buttler (33.33) and Jonny Bairstow (33.70) - but there is no shortage of high-quality alternatives in the game.

Then there's the small matter of the captaincy. Pat Cummins is the leading candidate and now CA is likely to be forced to jump headlong into the decision of appointing him at least six months before it would have wanted to. There is still some talk of a return to Steven Smith - and what a circle that would complete if he was to return in these circumstances - but it won't happen. He will, however, have a vital senior role to play alongside Cummins.

A reminder, too, that while Cummins was appointed New South Wales' one-day captain; he has never led in a first-class match.

Paine remained the Test captain until 2021, when he retired from international cricket, passing the baton to Cummins.

There are calls for his successor resign amid the resurfacing of the allegations of Sandpapergate.

Australia captain, Pat Cummins, much like his fellow bowlers, is in the eye of the sandpapergate storm at the moment.

Cameron Bancroft has claimed the whole Australia team knew about the 2018 sandpaper plot in explosive revelations that will heap pressure on the current captain.

In a detailed testimony, published by the West Australian;batter Bancroft - the player caught with the sandpaper during the Test match against South Africa - has given arguably the most complete account of the events in Cape Town eight years ago.

"In 2018 not the entire truth was told," said Bancroft. "I have never been completely honest about what happened."

For the past two weeks, Australian cricket has been embroiled in a debate over the ball-tampering saga following the publication of Usman Khawaja's autobiography.

Also Read: Revelations

Khawaja wrote that the whole Australia team knew of the plot, claims supported by David Warner and Chadd Sayers. Cummins described Khawaja's account as "wrong" and "nonsense."

Also Read: Mixed Messages

On the day CA announced a forum into the sandpaper episode, Bancroft published his account, explaining he was motivated by the news conference given by Cummins.

"The final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins' press conference," said Bancroft. "It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone."

"What I saw, experienced and lived with - not only him, but everyone else on that tour in South Africa - is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously when he has spoken on this time."

Opener Bancroft was given a nine-month ban for his part in the plot. Steve Smith was stripped of the Australia captaincy and given a year-long ban; the same suspension was given to vice-captain Warner. No other players or coaches were punished.

In his more than 4 000-word piece, Bancroft has claimed:

  • Sandpaper was first used during the second Test against South Africa – the match before Bancroft was caught.
  • Bancroft had conversations with the Australia seamers – Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether the ball was "swinging enough."
  • Before the third day of the second Test; the entire playing group and staff had "celebrations" about the effect of the sandpaper.
  • When Bancroft was caught during the third Test, then Australia coach Darren Lehmann told 12th man Peter Handscomb to "get the sandpaper off Bangers now."

Bancroft found the publication of a joint-statement by the Australia bowlers in 2021 "deeply painful".

Therefore, this day of reckoning was always going to come. Let's be clear - as long as there has been cricket; there has been ball-tampering. There is no point hiding from the fact.

Back in the day, it was about shining the ball, maybe using something like a sweet to get a sheen on one side. Reverse swing was a ball-tampering game - changer. There was a requirement for a wearing process, roughing up and drying the ball.

To get one thing straight, whether a ball is being tampered with or not; it belongs to the bowlers. It is the bowling attack's weapon. As much as a bowler wouldn't fiddle with a batsman's bat – sanding an edge or changing the grip - a batsman would not work on the ball without the knowledge of a bowler.

Some might wonder why revelations relating to the sandpaper controversy have not come to light before. Only when a player has retired, or believe their time as an international cricketer has come to an end, do they feel more comfortable to speak up.

Smith was captain and should've been in control of his team. Warner cooked up the sandpaper idea. Bancroft executed it. If they did take bullets, they were bullets they deserved.

Now, the spotlight has fallen on Pat Cummins, whose agent has repeated his client's version of events in the last 24 hours.

The junior bowler at the time, Cummins has ascended to the captaincy, often joked to be the second-most important job in Australia; behind only the prime minister.

Cummins is not a typical Australian captain. He is not abrasive or in your face. When he says he has worked hard to correct the image of his team; he is credible. Then again, he missed a trick to really prove Australia are no longer a win-at-all-costs outfit with the Jonny Bairstow stumping in the 2023 Ashes Test at Lord's.

After everything he said in public and the way he has been backed by CA, there seems to be no obvious suggestion Cummins has considered resigning, or that he will be sacked.

He is due to lead Australia in the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December.

Looking ahead to that match, it is difficult to see how the build-up will be anything other than a circus, dominated by questions about sandpaper, who knew what and who said what to whom.

The litmus test for Cummins will be the public reaction. Remember, that Test is being played in Bancroft's home city (Perth), in the state of the newspaper where his 4 000-word testimony was first published.

If Cummins is still in his position by then, the response of the Perth crowd to the captain will be very interesting.

Even if Cummins does get through that, the Australian media will not let up. This is a huge story, one of the biggest in the history of Australia sport. The press will bang away until they feel they have got the truth.

What about next summer's Ashes? If Cummins is tossing the coin at Trent Bridge on 18 June; then he is extraordinarily resilient.

He has said he never wants to talk about sandpaper again, which is ludicrous when you think what he will face on that tour: scrutiny from the media, constant baiting from the crowds.

Cummins will have to decide if he was the stomach for all of that and whether he can see it through.

His way out could be to resign, without admitting guilt. To say the speculation has become a distraction for the team and the pressure is taking a toll on his family life – we have seen more pictures from Australia overnight of Cummins being confronted outside his home.

Cummins could perhaps continue in the ranks, just as Warner and Smith did. A resignation without an admission of guilt may also take the heat off the other bowlers – Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon.

Whether Cummins continues or not; questions will remain for others who were in Cape Town, CA and the whole culture of the sport in that country.

Looking now at what happened in 2018, it appears there was an attitude in the Australia camp that they were fireproof; that they could get away with anything.

Credit goes to their media manager Kate Hutchison, who, according to Bancroft, made a stand about what was going on and knew what would happen if and when the Aussies got caught.

What about the others involved, coaches who were supposed to guide and protect young men? Darren Lehmann and his position at Northamptonshire or David Saker, who has recently been working with England.

Ca has seemed so reluctant to get involved. If the big idea was to give individuals the opportunity to "tell their truth" behind closed doors, it is surely dead in the water.

What about telling THE truth? Nothing else is good enough.

I don't know why but the truth can be hard to admit. Holding it back can weigh in on you like a monkey on your back. With more backings about Khawaja's claims; it's quite clear what the truth is. Maybe Cummins should resign if his claims remain and more and more players come forward backing a full team knowledge.

A person who's holding back the truth should never captain a side. It sends a bad image of the team and what they represent.