A Repeat 'Offender'

Coach gets into trouble again

Apart from being a highly successful coach; Rassie Erasmus can best be described as controversial. He tends to speak his mind and will say it unfiltered. He's constantly getting into trouble as a result.

His latest remark has once again raised a few eyebrows.

World Rugby is reportedly set to review Springbok head coach Rassie Erasmus’ comments about double standards from match officials.

Sky Sports reports Erasmus’ remarks on Monday ahead of Saturday’s Nations Championship Test against Ireland in Dublin will be assessed under a framework introduced earlier this year to curb abuse of, and threats towards, officials.

It is understood that an independent three-person panel will decide whether his views were made to undermine confidence in officials. Punishments could include multiple-match bans.

Erasmus believes France committed 17 knee-drop tackles without sanction in the Boks’ 21-19 loss in Paris last week; 11 deserving at least a penalty and three a yellow card. He asked whether "manipulation" of the result explained why the TMO did not intervene.

He also predicted that a "technicality" would free Ireland flyhalf Sam Prendergast to play on Saturday, despite being cited for a hip-drop tackle in Ireland’s win over Fiji.

It is not yet known if Ireland fly-half Prendergast will be available for Saturday's crunch Nations Championship meeting at Dublin's Aviva Stadium; after he was cited for an alleged illegal hip-drop tackle against Fiji.

Despite the lack of ruling, Erasmus made it clear that he doesn't expect Prendergast to be penalised. "We are in the northern hemisphere," Erasmus said. "I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play."

"We all thought it's an immediate red card. Everybody watched the game live because that's exactly what they said the hip-drop tackle is," he said. "I swear I'm not moaning. I'm just trying to give you a perspective of somebody who comes and plays, for example, in France or in Ireland."

Ireland and South Africa have enjoyed an intense and, at times, fraught rivalry in recent years; with Ireland head coach Andy Farrell winning three of his five meetings against the Springboks.

However, South Africa were victorious in the most recent chapter of the rivalry, winning in Dublin a year ago in a game which saw five Irish players carded.

Should he be available, Prendergast would be expected to start at no. 10 on Saturday; something Erasmus believes would not be fair given his tackle last weekend.

"It's difficult to understand when the TMO sits there and he sees that," he said. "And it was something we discussed at the World Rugby meeting, and the examples of how it is was shown over and over, and we all had input. Somebody sees that and he decides there's nothing wrong with that."

On Monday, Erasmus questioned why many of France's knee-drop tackles he believed to be illegal weren't reviewed by the video referee.

"Let's say 11 of those were at least a penalty and three I thought was at least three yellow cards. And not one was sanctioned and not one was showed out or cited," Erasmus said in widely-reported quotes.

"I'll send you the playlist but I'll get into trouble… So I can't send the playlist to anybody and we can only send five clips to World Rugby. So we'll probably query it but the answer will probably be: 'Yes, it was a mistake, it should have been penalised'.

"On numerous times we mentioned to the referee 'we think there's a knee-drop tackle'. I'm saying to you my feeling is that knee-drop tackles is out. They happened 17 times in our game. Not one was penalised."

"And if the TMO didn't see it, then maybe technology must be better. If he saw it and ignored it, what does that boil down to? Manipulation of the game or the result? Or players getting injured?

"So, all I'm asking is don't take the TMOs out and discourage them to get involved. Then the wrong team will win and players will get injured. That's all I'm saying."

The coach explained and defended his position at Monday’s team-naming press conference in Dublin this week; saying he will always keep the option on the table for any reason that may benefit his team.

Last weekend, Erasmus switched his starting front row for his reserve front row at the last minute, leading to the unusual sight of three starters wearing reserve jersey numbers. The last time he deployed the strategy was also swapping the front rows against New Zealand in Cape Town; when Erasmus cited the weather conditions as the reason for the change.

The coach said, "I’ll say it honest" before launching into an explanation for the Paris change at his latest press conference, and explained why he names his teams earlier in the week than other Test sides.

The explanation wasn’t prompted by a question about his tactics but by one on another famous habit of his: naming his opponents’ matchday 23 before they do.

"I get into trouble when I do that. People say I’m arrogant," he grinned. "I’ve got a fairly good idea."

"That’s why we announce our team on Monday, and I get into trouble when we change things. We announce it on a Monday, and I’ll say it honest, for us as a team environment, if a team isn’t announced on a Monday, the speculation is Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and it gets into the camp. And the players have social media and see 'I think this guy should be playing'."

"You announce it internally on a Sunday night so players don’t get pulled into that vibe of 'but I should get a chance'. That’s how we operate a Springboks team, while one team is playing, the other is supporting."

"Why do we change props after Thursday? Because we see the team they’ve picked, and Julien Marchand would have played, and when we saw this we thought let’s make a change. We probably could have done that when they announce the team on Thursday, but the laws say you can do it the next morning before the game."

"This is honest, we thought, okay, let’s get Jan-Hendrik (Wessels), Thomas (du Toit) and Gerhard (Steenekamp) at the stadium; maybe we need them next year at the World Cup under pressure starting a big Test match for us, and they’re going to play against one of the best scrummaging hookers, and then he went through just before the game."

"And that’s why we changed them; we announced our team, they brought out a team on Thursday, we thought okay, this is going to be proper pressure for Jan-Hendrik."

"If people are going to keep getting upset about that, I’m apologising – I’m not apologising that I’m doing it, I’m apologising that you’re going to get upset, always."

"This is the team that we announce, and if Ireland come with a team on Thursday that we don’t think they’re going to play, we might make some changes."

Former Ireland lock, Donal Lenihan, says Rassie Erasmus knows exactly what he’s doing by taking the pressure off the Springboks ahead of Saturday’s clash in Dublin.

In a wide-ranging interview with RTÉ’s Inside Sport, Lenihan said the double World Cup winner was an expert at shifting attention away from his players and towards match officials; particularly in the build-up to important Tests.

"There’s elements of truth in what he’s saying," Lenihan said. "But I think he needs to be very careful when he comes out and says, ‘the right team must win’. This is what Rassie does. He’s a past master, especially after defeat, of taking the pressure off his players and putting it onto the officials in a way."

Erasmus has twice been banned by World Rugby for publicly criticising match officials. In 2021, after a 62-minute video attacking referee Nic Berry during the British & Irish Lions series, he received a two-month ban from all rugby activity and a match-day ban until September 2022.

In November 2022, the double World Cup winner was banned for two Tests after tweets criticising Wayne Barnes following South Africa’s loss to France.

World Rugby has since issued Erasmus a six match ban.

SA Rugby has asked World Rugby for a full and urgent misconduct hearing after Springbok head coach Rassie Erasmus was hit with an immediate six-match ban.

The panel, chaired by Australia's Adam Casselden SC, ruled that Erasmus' comments crossed the line into serious misconduct. They concluded that his words suggested match officials were biased or deliberately tried to change the outcome of the game. According to the panel, this was an unacceptable attack on the credibility and integrity of the referees.

In response, SA Rugby stated that while it respects World Rugby's process, it wants a full hearing so Erasmus can explain the context of his words.

"An SA Rugby spokesperson said that the organisation respected the process but had requested an opportunity for its coach to contextualise his comments and assure the panel that it was not his intention to allege that any match official had acted with ulterior motives," the union said.

World Rugby stressed that while debating refereeing decisions is normal; teams must use official channels rather than making public remarks that question an official's honesty.

It's because of the serious nature of the charge, SA Rugby hopes the hearing will happen quickly. The union added that it will not make any more public comments until the hearing is finished.

While I'm all for honesty, people should keep it in check and say it where appropriate. As seen above, being honest in public can come with consequences. It's best to know what to say and when to say it.